Children's Methods of Calculation
CCh Note: Activities like counting backwards in Predict A Count (see Sarah's example in this link), Smarties and Take A Score lead children to 'discover' negative numbers. It is not so much their existence which is a discovery, especially for students who have experienced a very cold winter; it is investigating how to operate with them that leads to an 'aha' about the broader structure of the number system.
One of the principles of Calculating Changes is children are allowed time to explore and develop their own algorithms (calculating procedures). This means refraining from imposing refined adult methods. The time gained by not filling hours attempting to press home methods that children find difficult, irrelevant or confusing is well spent listening to, celebrating and building on children's methods such as:
From Page 18 Calculators, Children and Mathematics
Children began to make use of negative numbers in their mental calculations. The method of subtraction shown in Figure 3.8 was discovered independently in several classrooms, by children who liked to work from the left-hand end of a calculation. The child whose work is shown writes the result of the calculation on the first line, and then records an explanation of the steps used.

Subtracting Using Negatives
Figure 3.8, p.18. Calculators, Children and Mathematics.

Thus children who use calculators quickly become able to interpret negative displays on the calculator, and to make sense of negative numbers in which their use is appropriate. The teachers have been ingenious in devising situations such as the 'Smarties' game, which were within the children's comprehension and where it was necessary to extend the number-line below zero. Children have also found their own uses for negative numbers, such as the subtraction method shown in Figure 3.8.

Children's methods of subtraction are also taken up in the Calculating Changes Leaders' Section. See Davina & Friends Learn to Subtract and Violet Blossoms in the Stories section.


Return to C.A.N. Report Index

Calculating Changes ... is a division of ... Mathematics Centre